Tag: Senior journalist

Blood Sanders - The Great Forest Heist

Blood Sanders – The Great Forest Heist’ by Sudhakar Reddy Udumula, spill the beans of criminal politician nexus to turn Seshachalam bald

Blood Sanders – The Great Forest Heist, is a maiden book of Sudhakar Reddy Udumula, a senior journalist with over three decades of crime reporting. He donned the author’s cap, to expose the nefarious criminal network and operations associated with the Red Sanders smuggling from the dense forests of Seshachalam in South India, which culminates in the cosy homes in China and Japan. Hon’ble Mr Justice N.V. Ramana, Chief Justice of India; E – Launched the book. Later an eminent panel comprising of M.V. Krishna Rao, IPS, Former DG SSB; P. Raghuveer, IFS, Retired Principal Chief Conservator of Forests; Prof. Madabhusi Sridhar, Dean, School of Law, Mahindra University & Former CIC; participated in a panel discussion moderated by Uma Sudhir, Executive Editor, NDTV; today at Bhaskara Auditorium.

The author drawing upon his immense exposure of reporting on the Red Sanders smuggling network strongly felt the need to spill the beans about the criminal, politician, bureaucrat nexus in annihilating the forests and depriving the country of its rich resources. The book is pertinent today more than ever, as the forests are witnessing an unprecedented upsurge in smuggling. Even during the Covid-19 pandemic that shook the world, smuggling went about unhindered. The incessant ringing of alarm bells harbingers the extinction of the endangered Red sanders species unique to the South of India, a decade from now.

The current plight of Red Sanders or ‘red gold’ is due to it being the source of funding political and criminal deeds in and around Rayalaseema of Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka in South India. It is believed to have turned many into millionaires while claiming the lives of the illegal woodcutters who form the frontline of this organised crime syndicate. The book is the first step in understanding the complex network that drives this illegal trade across borders and the number of players involved from top to bottom.

The book comprises ten chapters, each dealing with a different facet of the organized crime syndicate that is red sanders smuggling. In the opening chapter, the book explores different reasons why red sanders is considered valuable; it also briefly looks at the wood’s significance to Indian and different world cultures. The next three chapters provide a detailed insight into the inception of the world of red sanders smugglers, along with vignettes of their popular scandals. Focusing on the smuggling process at the ground level, the fifth chapter fleshes out structures, stages, and the logistics involved in carrying out this international racket. The two subsequent chapters dive into countermeasures initiated by the State to curtail red sanders smuggling, including the formation of a Special Task Force, and how these measures fared over time.

Included in it is also an interesting firsthand experience of the author who journeyed with the police and forest forces that protect red sanders species. ‘Chittoor Encounter’ narrates the horrible incident that took place in April 2015, along with an objective commentary at points on the same. A racket that is as huge in scope and extent as red sanders smuggling cannot have been carried out without accomplices, so the next chapter explores the details of the intricate connections among elections, politicians, and smugglers. Since all roads, in this case, lead to China, the penultimate chapter cuts through to the source of the reasons why China is obsessed over red sanders and what factors lead to the demand that is quenched only by a global racket. In the last chapter, the book enumerates the measures that need to be observed in letter and spirit to ensure zero felling and to protect, as well as to conserve, the endangered species of red sanders.

Full text of the speech delivered by Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India Shri Justice N V Ramana at the launch of book “Blood Sanders: The Great Forest Heist” authored by Shri Sudhakar Reddy Udumula, Senior Journalist.

The book ‘Blood Sanders’ that we are holding in our hands today is the result of diligent research and a great amount of hard work put in by Sri Udumula Sudhakar Reddy. He has been tracking this subject as a professional news reporter for nearly two decades. He travelled extensively in the habitat of red sanders which is a difficult terrain to walk through. He had first-hand interaction with the key players of the smuggling racket and also those who struggled to enforce the law. I think he is the most qualified person to deal with this subject.

When he first approached me for this event, I had no choice but to say yes for more than one reason. Firstly, I knew him as a journalist from his formative days as a crime reporter. I am happy to note that he rose to the rank of Editor in a leading English daily. Secondly, I and his uncle Udumula Joji Reddy were together as students in S V V N Degree College, Amaravathi. His father, Sri Udumula Rayapa Reddy Garu, a few years senior to me, is an agriculturist who hailed from Jagannadhapuram village which is adjacent to my native village Ponnavaram.

మా ఊరూ వాడా గుర్తొస్తొన్నాయి. ఆ మంచి రోజులూ, ఆన్నటి మిత్రులు గుర్తొకొస్తొన్నార్త. ఊరికి వెళ్లాలని ఎప్పటినండో అనకంటున్నాన. త్వరలో వీలు చేస్తకోవటానికి ప్రయత్నాస్తొన్నాన. (I am reminded of my village, good old days and great friends. I have been longing to visit my village. Hope to do so very soon).

As described by Sudhakar, his father Rayapa Reddy Garu is well known in our area for his integrity and resilience. I couldn’t have said no, to this worthy son of a worthy father. Sudhakar Reddy is an award-winning journalist. He has won national and international laurels for his work.

His book gives insights into what all has gone wrong with the fragile ecosystem spread over Chittoor, Nellore, Prakasam, Kadapa and Kurnool districts of Andhra Pradesh. Red Sanders thrived in this habitat till a few decades ago. Now it is facing the threat of extinction. Like all good things in this world, Red Sanders also fell prey to the greed of man. Sri Sudhakar explains how the high and mighty fuelled this project of destruction. The destruction, not only of the Red Sanders species but of the ecosystem as a whole. This species is known for preventing forest fires from spreading in the vulnerable forests of Seshachalam hills. The consequences of this ecological destruction are there for us to see globally. The need of the hour is to address these issues locally.

According to an estimate presented by the author, in the last two decades, nearly 60 lakh Red Sanders trees were cut. Smuggling from the forest area spread over 5,30,097 hectares resulted in the arrest of over 2000 persons from the neighbouring state alone. Many have lost lives. Lawbreakers as well as enforcers of the law suffered fatalities. The author rightly named the book ‘Blood Sanders’, as smuggling of this high-value timber has led to unprecedented bloodshed. It is second only to sandalwood smuggling, perhaps.

As the author mentions, ‘The AP Forest Act’ was amended in 2016 to deal sternly with the smuggling of Red Sanders. However, what is lacking is the necessary will to enforce these laws. This is where the media needs to play its role. The collective failures of individuals and institutions entrusted with the role of protectors need to be highlighted by the media. People need to be made aware of deficiencies in the process. This job can only be done by the media.

As a person whose first job was that of a journalist, I am taking the liberty to share a few thoughts on present-day media. The concept of investigative journalism is, unfortunately, vanishing from the media canvas. It is true at least in the Indian context. When we were growing up, we eagerly looked forward to newspapers exposing big scandals. The newspapers never disappointed us.

In the past, we have witnessed newspaper reports on scandals and misconduct creating waves leading to serious consequences. Barring one or two, I don’t recall any story of such magnitude in recent years. Everything in our garden appears to be rosy. I leave it to you to arrive at your own conclusions.

I am reminded of what Gandhi Ji said about newspapers, I quote:

“The newspapers should be read for the study of facts. They should not be allowed to kill the habit of independent thinking.”

I hope the media introspects and tests itself against these words of Mahatma.

Coming back to the book that we released today, Sudhakar Reddy made some very good suggestions for the protection and conservation of Red Sanders and the Seshachalam Forest Ecosystem. It includes creating a conducive atmosphere for the cultivation, harvest and trade of Red Sanders.

I have a suggestion to make. Locals, if involved in conservation efforts, will make a huge difference. Tiger reserves and wildlife sanctuaries have benefitted from engaging tribals who are forest dwellers as forest guards. With this approach, prospective poachers of wildlife were turned into wildlife protectors as they found dependable livelihood. The authorities here can try this method in Seshachalam by way of employing tribals and other forest dwellers as forest guards. Possibly, the smugglers may then find it difficult to attract them for the job of tree felling.

Let me not come between you and the panel of experienced and knowledgeable experts who are going to enlighten the gathering about the wide gamut of issues involved. I wish Sudhakar Reddy all the very best in his future endeavours. Keep up your good work.

I thank Sudhakar Reddy and the organisers for giving me the opportunity to take part in this event. Namaskaram.

Some excerpts from the book

The data collated from the past two decades indicate government machinery seizing over 15,000 MT of Red Sanders and arresting over 30,000 persons involved in the illegal trade of the wood. Since smugglers are interested only in the heartwood, it is seen that in most of the cases, for each tree felled, they extract only one Red Sanders log, which is then carried manually to the loading point by the smugglers. On average, if each log weighs 25kg, it would mean 40 logs per metric tonne of wood seized. Thus 15,000 MT indicates six lakh logs were seized, through which we can infer that 6 lakh Red Sanders trees have been felled illegally in the past two decades in Andhra Pradesh. It is estimated that the seizures account for only 10 per cent of illegal felling. That would indicate that a staggering 60 lakh Red Sanders trees, mostly of higher gift classes, have been felled. If we assume even a 30 per cent efficiency in seizures, it would amount to illegal felling of 20 lakh Red Sanders trees in the past 20 years.

The impact of the selective felling (since the coveted heartwood is found in Red Sanders trees which have a girth of above 70 cm only) can be seen in the skewed girth class distribution of Red Sanders in Seshachalam Hills. Less than 10 per cent of the Red Sanders trees in Seshachalam forests fall in the high girth class. If the current trend of smuggling goes unchecked, it will be in a matter of a decade be impossible to spot a Red Sanders tree with a girth of 70 cm or over.

It is said that this brand of woodcutters from ‘Veerappan forest’ is used as leverage by middlemen to seek more labour wages while also labelling an entire section of migrants as ‘criminals’. This only gives an excuse to the police to hunt the illegal woodcutters down in the name of Veerappan. Reports state that more than 2,000 Dalit and tribal labour migrant woodcutters from Tamil Nadu have been jailed. The majority of the people arrested during operations by the security forces are woodcutters, who are branded as smugglers and put in jails for a long time even if they are unable to provide any information about the kingpins. The same doesn’t apply to the key operatives who get bail quickly. There have been several instances of these. Many smugglers, including Dawood Shahul Hameed, have fled the country after obtaining bail.

The Kingpin

The kingpin of the business is Dawood Shahul Hameed, one of the most wanted fugitives for India. The rest of the smugglers, who remain now, are working for him under some direction. Many of them are Chennai or Bengaluru-based, and most of the negotiations are done in UAE and such countries. Most of the smugglers from India run regular businesses, such as shopping complexes, in Dubai too.

Then there is the issue of how multi-crore smuggling operations can get away with it more often not. There are suspicions that those within the larger political structures in Andhra Pradesh and Indian politics facilitate this. In turn, their political career is funded by these smugglers. Given that most smugglers go scot-free and that the lower-level smugglers rarely know of the bigger picture, the information around these smuggling operations and details of it aren’t easy to come by.

A little information about Red Sanders smuggling needs to be gathered piece by piece from various reluctant sources. This book is the culmination of two decades of reporting and probing

When things began to heat up, Interpol also joined the fight based on the request of AP police through Central Bureau of Investigation and issued a red corner notice against KGR. Once the notice was issued, the Mauritius police arrested KGR and deported him to India under a murder charge.

Unprecedented Diplomatic action

For this to happen, the Special Task Force and AP police were doing everything in their power to get KGR back in the country. The Andhra police tried to convince the Central government that deportation was the only way to get KGR from Mauritius. They first appealed to the then Minister of External Affairs, Sushma Swaraj, and the higher courts of India. “Whatever DGP says, you must do it. It is a very prestigious case for us. How can this man defy us like this? In the last six months, this man has moved through 20 countries. “We cannot allow this,” JV Ramudu quoted Sushma Swaraj as saying to the Indian High Commissioner in Mauritius when the former DGP met her. This interaction with Sushma Swaraj resulted in another unprecedented move. With the help of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, KGR’s deportation order in Mauritius was signed by then Mauritius Prime Minister Anerood Jugnauth himself. Usually, this would be done by a Secretary of State.

Burma refugees- the conduit

Burma refugees, who had started to become vendors in many illegal trades for their survival, got involved with Red Sanders smuggling a few decades ago. Since they knew the land routes and passageways out of the country, they used their knowledge to export the wood. They direct and guide the transport of the Red Sanders logs and get paid handsomely as they have built a strong base in cities such as Chennai, where the famous Burma Bazaar is known to trade in all things illegal.

Their modus operandi is to have the logs collected from loading points or the godowns sent to Visakhapatnam and to Odisha from there. Next, they reach West Bengal and ultimately arrive in Moreh, near the Indo-Myanmar border, where many Red Sanders smugglers are ready to buy the logs. These buyers would then transport the logs by road to China.

It poses a Hawala Money Hundreds of millions are made from this racket because of its demand abroad. And the payments are brought back into the country through various routes. Many use the hawala route to bring the money in as gold and dollars. The link between Red Sanders smuggling and the underworld worries Neither politicians nor corrupt administrative executives could pull this off alone. It is only with the concerted effort that they have been succeeding for the most part in smuggling Red Sanders for nearly two decades now. Here the politics and profitable criminal activities intermingle and become a united and self-reinforcing whole.

Politicians extend protection to this illegal and unlawful economy, which in turn becomes the milch cow for gaining political power by funding elections. This indicates that the Red Sanders mafia is one whose roots extend to very remote corners of our society’s socio-political and economic structures. It is also helpful to remember, in this connection, that the criminalisation of the export of Red Sanders existed for a long time, and that murders, kidnapping and rackets had become the tools by which to climb the political ladder and exercise power to make enormous profits in different public and private sectors.

Red Sanders Museums

The Chinese obsession with Red Sanders was about to grow only more formidable as time went on. The Chinese attempted to turn the palaces into museums first. They built the most expensive Red Sanders museum, where replicas of real-life historic landscapes and collected ancient art pieces from Beijing and other parts of China were preserved in elaborate painstakingly-accurate miniature models for future generations.

Cross border Mafia

The Chinese mafia, which drives Red Sanders smuggling, has much demand for it. Its scarcity elsewhere around the world made the Chinese mafia zero in on the Seshachalam forest ranges for the wood.

Chinese smugglers hail from different parts of China, including Fujian province, from Naipu state of Henan province, and Hujian. Like the organisational structure of the native smugglers, many of the main Chinese smugglers do not themselves come to India but appoint a Chinese national living here to smuggle the wood for them for handsome pay classes, have been felled. If we assume even a 30 per cent efficiency in seizures, it would amount to illegal felling of 20 lakh Red Sanders trees in the past 20 years.

Indian media powerful but suffers perception issues - Alok Mehta, senior journalist and Padma Shri awardee

Indian media powerful but suffers perception issues – Alok Mehta, senior journalist and Padma Shri awardee

Mumbai: Lamenting the fact that to catch eyeballs with sensational news, tabloid journalism has got mixed up with serious journalism, senior journalist and Padma Shri awardee Alok Mehta has said that despite criticism, Indian media is free and powerful but its credibility perception has gone down.

“Tabloid journalism which was very strong earlier has got mixed with serious journalism today in newspapers as well as TV Channels. Entertainment and sensationalism have got mixed up with news and headlines have become sensational to increase sales. Despite the fact that Indian news media is very strong, powerful and enjoys huge freedom it suffers from perception issues and its credibility has gone down over the years” said Mehta.

He was speaking to with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD Governance Now, during the webcast of Visionary Talk series held by public policy and governance analysis platform.

Adding that even though Indian news media is very strong and enjoys huge freedom, the veteran journalist and editor said that it suffers from perception issues and its credibility has gone down over the years.

“While it is not correct to say things are completely bad, today media is not able to do what it should be doing. Editors/media owners must shun arrogance and objectively accept constructive criticism.”

Mehta observed that since independence over the last fifty years media has grown and the no. of newspapers and news channels across the country has increased and news readership and consumption has increased over the years. Inspite of this, media is not able to do what it should be doing because it is competing with each other.

“As against earlier, today the difference is that media has expanded and people are able to express their views through YouTube or social media. Despite that, competition and the race to be one up against the other is damaging the media. It is not so much political interference but competition amongst themselves and criticism against their own colleagues that is damaging the media. We are not ready to accept our shortcomings but competing to be ahead of each other in the race” he said.

Recalling many instances when mistakes made by earlier editors led to closure of some publications and problems exacerbated after with many of their colleagues and contemporaries made several complaints he said, “Still there was camaraderie. Today the mentality in media is that either you are with me or you are against me. Competition must be healthy.”

Speaking on reporting around Covid -19, Mehta, who is also a recipient of several national and state awards said that media must self- regulate while reporting on pandemic and keep in mind the impact of their stories on the minds of children and elders at home who are facing depression due to huge negative reporting on covid.

Responding to question if authenticity of news has come down, Mehta added that people relate to brands for credibility of reporting and that credibility has been tarnished. News analysis should be left to editorial.

“News reporting has to be based on facts. Today in India everybody wants to comment along with news. Analysis of news should be left to editorial. But in India that demarcation is broken. Today everyone is commenting on news. Reporters are giving commentary on news and demarcation between news and analysis is broken”

“TV not in the business of news; it is in the business of polarization” Vir Sanghvi, senior journalist, columnist, and author

“TV not in the business of news; it is in the business of polarization” Vir Sanghvi, senior journalist, columnist, and author

India: Senior journalist, columnist, and author, Vir Sanghvi has said that television news these days has a loose relationship with truth, is not telling truth and polarizing opinions.

In a live webcast with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now during the Visionary Talk series held by the public policy and governance analysis platform, the senior editor has said that news television does not tell the truth nor it has any interest to do so.

“News has always been driven by people with narratives. It is in the business of polarizing opinions and sensationalizing news. It has a very loose and relaxed relationship with truth. Sometimes when the truth is convenient it broadcasts it, other times it plays it up. Unfortunately the truth these days is a scarce commodity” said Sanghvi.

While speaking on fierce competition between news channels and hiking up ratings, Sanghvi said that competition within and between channels is not a new phenomenon and the nature of news since he was an active part of news has now changed. “The argument then was that you are only as good as the news you cover. There would be a discussion of 10-15 mins to illuminate the issue the package had set out for. That model of TV is dead” Sanghvi said .

He added that now nobody can afford to have bureaus and reporters and you now have studios. As against 12-14 guests on OB’s (outdoor broadcasting vans) earlier, now you have guests on Zoom so cost is zero. “You don’t worry much about news. You worry about opinion, creating excitement and you want people to shout in the studio and have a WWF element to it. It seems to be getting ratings. This is not a news channel in any significant sense of term and new genre half way between fiction and news.”

Adding that the definition and ratings of news and entertainment channels are blurring, Sanghvi, said, ‘‘if you look at the universe for English news as a proportion of total TV universe, it is in the proportion of 0.1%-0.2% which even in Hindi news is not so low. This is nowhere compared to entertainment channels.”

“In general news channels are on decline all over the world and eventually go the way of newspapers. In another two years the same will happen with news television. Why would you want to watch news TV for 1 hour when you can get it in real time, on demand, on your mobile phone” he said.

He also said that unlike the sophisticated measurement systems used in the US or the UK where they look for demographics like how many people are likely to stay with the channel or buy things, Indian advertising is number centric. FTA (free to air) channels do not get much revenue out of subscription and look for advertising.

On social media fanning false information Sanghvi said the government is always reluctant to regulate because no one knows how to regulate the new media but at some stage it will have to bite the bullet.